LW Acekias

View Original

Understanding Asset Classes and Index Performance

Time to read: 4 to 5 minutes.

Level: Fundamental.

Category: Education Note.


Investment asset class and indexes are two important concepts in the field of finance and investing. An asset class is a group of similar investments that have similar characteristics, risks, and returns.

Asset Class Definition and Classification

Asset class definition and classification are fundamental concepts in the field of investment management. An asset class refers to a group of financial instruments with similar characteristics and behavior in the marketplace. The classification of investments into asset classes is a systematic process that aids investors and financial professionals in understanding and organizing the diverse range of financial instruments available.

An asset class is typically defined by a set of common features, such as the type of underlying asset, investment purpose, risk profile, and return characteristics. Common asset classes include equities (stocks), fixed income (bonds), cash and cash equivalents, and alternative investments like real estate and commodities.

To classify investments into asset classes, analysts consider the primary drivers of risk and return for each type of investment. Equities, for example, represent ownership in a company and are influenced by factors such as corporate performance and economic conditions. Fixed income securities, on the other hand, involve loans to entities and are affected by interest rate movements and credit risk.

The process of classification involves grouping similar investments together based on their inherent characteristics, allowing for clearer analysis and comparison. This classification assists investors in constructing diversified portfolios that align with their risk tolerance, investment objectives, and time horizon.

Furthermore, asset class classification serves as a foundation for strategic asset allocation, a key component of portfolio management. By understanding the characteristics of different asset classes, investors can determine optimal weightings within their portfolios to achieve a balance between risk and return.

Some of the main asset classes are:

  • Equities or stocks: These are shares of ownership in a company. They offer the potential for high returns, but also carry high risks. Equities can be further divided into subcategories based on size, sector, geography, style, and other factors.

  • Fixed-income securities or bonds: These are debt instruments that pay a fixed amount of interest and return the principal at maturity. They offer lower returns, but also lower risks than equities. Bonds can be issued by governments, corporations, or other entities, and can vary in quality, duration, and currency.

  • Cash or cash equivalents: These are short-term, liquid, and low-risk investments, such as money market funds, certificates of deposit, or treasury bills. They offer the lowest returns, but also the highest safety and liquidity.

  • Real estate or commodities: These are physical assets, such as land, buildings, metals, or agricultural products. They offer diversification benefits, as they tend to have low or negative correlation with other asset classes. They also offer protection against inflation, as their prices tend to rise with the general level of prices. However, they also have high volatility, high costs, and low liquidity.

Index Definition and Construction

An index is a collection of securities that represent a specific market segment or asset class. Investors use indexes as benchmarks to measure the performance of their portfolios and to identify opportunities and risks. For example, the S&P 500 Index is a widely used benchmark for the U.S. equity market, as it includes 500 large-cap companies from various sectors and industries. The Lehman Aggregate Bond Index is a common benchmark for the U.S. bond market, as it covers a broad range of fixed-income securities with different maturities and credit ratings. The MSCI World Index is a popular benchmark for the global equity market, as it covers over 1,600 companies from 23 developed countries.

Indexes are useful for investors, as they provide a way to compare the performance of their portfolios with the market, to assess the risk and return characteristics of different asset classes, and to construct diversified portfolios that match their objectives and preferences. However, indexes also have some limitations, such as:

  • They may not reflect the true performance of the market, as they are based on a sample of securities, not the entire universe of available investments.

  • They may not capture the impact of fees, taxes, and transaction costs, which can reduce the actual returns of investors.

  • They may not account for the changing dynamics of the market, as they are based on historical data and fixed methodologies, which may not adapt to new trends and developments.

More formally, an index is a statistical measure that represents the performance of a specific market segment or asset class. It serves as a benchmark, offering a numerical representation of the collective performance of a group of related financial instruments. The construction of an index involves a systematic and transparent methodology to accurately reflect the changes in the underlying market or asset class.

The first step in constructing an index is defining the selection criteria for the included financial instruments. This criteria could be based on factors such as market capitalization, sector classification, or specific financial metrics. The goal is to create a representative sample of the market or asset class in question.

Once the selection criteria are established, the index is constructed by calculating the weighted average performance of the chosen financial instruments. The weights assigned to each component are typically based on their market value, ensuring that larger components have a proportionally greater impact on the index's overall value.

The methodology for calculating the index value needs to be transparent and consistent over time. This transparency is essential for investors and other market participants to understand how the index is constructed and to facilitate accurate comparisons of performance. Revisions to the index methodology, if any, are communicated clearly to maintain the integrity and reliability of the benchmark.

Periodic rebalancing is a crucial aspect of index construction, ensuring that the index continues to accurately reflect the market or asset class it represents. Rebalancing involves adjusting the weights of the components based on changes in their market values or other relevant factors. This process helps prevent the index from becoming skewed due to fluctuations in individual asset values.

Asset Class and Index Performance and Characteristics

Asset class indexes are essential tools for investors seeking to gauge the performance of various asset classes within the financial markets. These indexes serve as benchmarks that enable market participants to assess the relative strength or weakness of specific asset categories. The importance of asset class indexes lies in their ability to provide a standardized measure of investment performance, facilitating comparisons and informed decision-making.

Investors utilize asset class indexes to gain insights into the overall market trends, identify potential opportunities, and manage risk within their portfolios. These benchmarks play a crucial role in strategic asset allocation, helping investors allocate their resources across different asset classes based on historical performance and risk considerations.

To use asset class indexes effectively, investors often employ them as reference points to evaluate the performance of their investment portfolios against the broader market. By comparing the returns of their portfolios to the corresponding asset class indexes, investors can assess the effectiveness of their investment strategies and make informed adjustments as needed.

Each asset class typically has a representative index that encapsulates its performance. For equities, the S&P 500 is a widely recognized index, reflecting the performance of large-cap U.S. stocks. In the fixed-income space, the Bloomberg Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index is commonly used to gauge the performance of the broader bond market. Real estate investment trusts (REITs) are often measured by the performance of indexes such as the MSCI US REIT Index. Meanwhile, commodities are tracked using indexes like the Bloomberg Commodity Index.

The historical performance of bonds over the past 25 years can be analyzed using data from the Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation (SBBI) Yearbook published by Ibbotson Associates. The SBBI Yearbook provides annual returns for various asset classes and inflation rates since 1926.

Historical (1926-2020) performance of major asset classes

Source: Stocks, Bonds, Bills, and Inflation® (SBBI®): 2020 Summary Edition.

The historical performance of bonds over the last 25 years indicates that bonds have yielded positive returns in both nominal and real terms. However, these returns have been lower, accompanied by lower risk compared to equities. Bonds have also served as diversifiers in a portfolio, exhibiting low or negative correlations with other asset classes. Nonetheless, bond yields have proven to be sensitive to changes in interest rates and credit quality, factors that can impact their future performance.

Relation with other part of the investment process.

Some of the most sought-after issues related to investment asset class and indexes are:

  • How to choose the appropriate asset allocation for a portfolio, based on the investor’s risk tolerance, time horizon, and goals.

  • How to diversify a portfolio across different asset classes, regions, sectors, and styles, to reduce the overall risk and enhance the expected return.

  • How to use thematic investing, which is an approach that seeks to capture the opportunities created by long-term structural trends and medium-term cyclicality across asset classes and regions

References:

  • Ilmanen, Antti. Expected Returns: An Investor’s Guide to Harvesting Market Rewards. Foreword by Clifford Asness. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 2011

  • Ilmanen, Antti. Expected Returns on Major Asset Classes. Charlottesville, VA: Research Foundation of CFA Institute, 2012.